American Eagle (AE) return policy?
I  bought two Favorite T-Shirts on a Buy One, Get One Half Off deal in  June.  I don't like the color of one of them; it's pale pink and I want a  deeper pink. The tags are still on the t-shirt, it's never been worn,  and I still have the receipt. I know AE doesn't have a time limit on  returning products, so I can still get my money back.  They have more Favorite T-Shirts for the same price (slightly different  style, though - the style I have is now gone) and I'd just like to swap  for color. However, I bought it on a Buy One, Half Off sale, and that  sale has ended. They'd probably just give me the half back and make me  pay the other half for the new t-shirt.  If I take the t-shirt I want to exchange in, with the tags on it, and  say it was a gift and I don't have the receipt, will they just exchange  it for a new one? 
Fashion & Accessories - 6 Answers
Random Answers, Critics, Comments, Opinions :
1 :
Probably not =[
2 :
As soon as you're one foot out the door, it's unreturnable.
3 :
I think if your just exchanging  the shirt it wont matter.
4 :
No,  most likely they wouldn't because there's a new style now, and if the  old one is still in the store it's most likely on sale. They'll probably  give you the current value of the old one without a receipt, which I'm  guessing will be less than t he new one.
5 :
No they wont  make you pay i use to work in retail and if its the same shirt just a  different color you dont have to pay the difference. If you try to  exchange it without a reciept they will give you the lowest price it was  sold at in the last couple months so you might get less than what you  spent on it if you say you have no reciept. But american eagle you can  return whenever, the reciept says if your not happy you can return it  they have to exchange it for you especially if you still have the tags  and reciept.
6 :
They should, I dont think its a problem